Until recently, the carbon locked into a building’s concrete, steel, and glass was something only specialists talked about. Planning officers asked about energy use, and procurement teams asked about price. That’s no longer the full picture. In London, major developments now have to report the carbon emitted across a building’s whole life before planning permission is granted. In the United States, federal and state governments are starting to favour lower-carbon materials in the projects they pay for.

These changes are turning carbon analysis from a voluntary sustainability exercise into a routine part of getting buildings approved and built.

London: whole life-cycle carbon in planning

The London Plan, adopted in 2021, includes a policy requiring developments referred to the Mayor, generally the largest schemes, to calculate whole life-cycle carbon emissions and show what they’re doing to reduce them. The Greater London Authority’s Whole Life-Cycle Carbon Assessments guidance explains how applicants should do this.

Whole life-cycle carbon means more than the carbon from running the building. It covers emissions from making and transporting materials, construction, maintenance and replacement over the building’s life, operational energy, and demolition and disposal at the end. Applicants submit an assessment at planning stage, then update it after construction based on what was actually built.

Because the planning submission has to show the choices made, teams now compare options such as retaining an existing structure, using lower-carbon concrete, or reducing basement depth earlier in design.

Across the UK more broadly, the RICS professional statement on whole life carbon assessment, updated in a second edition that took effect in July 2024, sets out a consistent method that surveyors and consultants follow, which makes assessments easier to compare between projects.

The US: Buy Clean and procurement

In the US, the push has come mostly through public procurement. California’s Buy Clean California Act set maximum global warming potential limits for certain materials used in state-funded projects, including structural steel, reinforcing steel, flat glass, and mineral wool insulation. Suppliers have to provide Environmental Product Declarations showing the carbon impact of their products.

At federal level, the Buy Clean initiative directs agencies to prioritise lower-carbon construction materials, such as concrete, steel, asphalt, and glass, in federally funded projects. Several other states have introduced their own Buy Clean policies.

Because public projects are such a large share of construction, these rules affect the whole supply chain. Manufacturers who publish EPDs and lower their products’ carbon footprint gain an advantage, and private developers increasingly use the same data.

What a carbon assessment actually involves

Whether for planning or procurement, carbon analysis follows a similar process.

The team starts with material quantities, usually taken from the design model or bill of quantities. Each material is then matched with carbon data, ideally from product-specific EPDs, otherwise from industry-average databases. The assessment covers defined life cycle stages: product manufacture, transport, construction, use and replacement, and end of life. Results are reported in kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent, often per square metre of floor area.

The useful part comes next. A good assessment shows where the carbon sits, typically in the structure, foundations, and façade, and tests alternatives. Swapping a cement blend, changing a structural grid, or retaining part of an existing building can change the total significantly.

Retrofit versus rebuild

One of the biggest effects of whole life carbon analysis is on the decision to demolish or retain. A new building can be very efficient to run, but demolishing an existing one and building a replacement releases a large amount of carbon up front. A whole life carbon comparison puts both options on the same basis, so the trade-off becomes visible.

In London, that comparison has become a regular part of debate over major redevelopment schemes, and some high-profile proposals to demolish existing buildings have faced strong challenges on carbon grounds. Developers now often need to justify demolition with a clear analysis showing why retention isn’t practical.

What this means for designers and suppliers

For design teams, carbon analysis is becoming a standard deliverable alongside cost plans and energy models. Running it early gives the most room to reduce carbon, because the big decisions about structure, form, and reuse happen during concept design.

For contractors and suppliers, EPDs are becoming a commercial requirement. Bids for public work in many US states, and for major schemes in London, increasingly ask for product-level carbon data.

For owners and investors, carbon results are starting to influence financing, valuation, and reporting. Lenders and tenants ask about embodied carbon more often than they did even a few years ago.

Practical steps for project teams

Project teams can prepare for these requirements with a few steps. Check what the local authority or funding body requires, and at which stages. Set a carbon target per square metre at the start of the project. Run a carbon comparison of retention and new-build options before choosing a direction. Ask suppliers for EPDs as early as possible. And plan for the post-construction update, by keeping records of the materials actually used.

Projects that build carbon analysis into their normal workflow tend to find that it shapes better decisions, and that the planning and procurement requirements become easier to meet.